Whenever I hear that Carey Heywood has a new book coming out, I am chomping at the bit to read it. And Why Not? definitely did not disappoint. I loved every word of it. The story is simple, Kasey is in love with Jake, her best friend’s older brother. But she just recently got engaged to Jake’s best friend. Then Jake comes home to this shock even though Jake has always seen her as a second little sister. Until she isn’t. Wait! Did I say the story line was simple? Sorry, I lied. It’s so much fun!! As usual, Carey writes with depth and precision that sucks you right into the story and the characters. You feel like they are your friends and you are hanging at the Diner with them going through everything together. There are some funny and sad misunderstandings along the way to getting everyone with whom they belong with. You’ll laugh, you’ll cry, you’ll shake your head. I highly recommend this book.